*Disclaimer – this post is written for the people of New
Community Church, but we welcome others to read along as well (it has been published publically for anyone
to see). Earlier this week the pastors of NCC chose to announce the specific
doctrinal reason that we have decided to leave our church over. The information
in this post shouldn’t be a surprise to anyone who received the video
announcement, from NCC leadership, about our departure. We want to be clear that we are not
undermining our church's leadership in sharing the below information. They have given us permission to post this. Also, this post
is quite lengthy, so I won’t go into details about where we are going in
Connecticut. That will be saved for a separate future post, along with details
about transferring the adoption to CT (which should be a fairly simple process).
By now, those who attend New Community Church have heard the
news that Adam and I will be leaving the church this spring. We will be moving
to Connecticut where Adam will take a Worship Pastor position at a church there.
It is with great sadness that we have chosen to make this life changing
decision. NCC has been Adam’s church home for over four years, and mine for
over three. We are covenant members, and have been fully committed to serving
here since we arrived. We love our NCC family with a deep Christ-like
affection, and as a result, this has
been one of the most difficult weeks of our lives.
The decision to leave New Community Church has never been an
easy one. It’s a decision we have been wrestling with for about a year now. Our
love for the pastors, elders, staff, and congregation of NCC runs incredibly
deep. We can’t even begin to describe the heartache, and pain, we are
experiencing as we think about leaving those we love so dearly. We knew that
leaving NCC would be excruciatingly difficult, and it has certainly proved to
be so.
At the same time, our love for Christ and His church, and
our love for the truth, and for upholding God's precious Word, is more
important to us than the pain we are currently experiencing. We stand firm in
our decision and know it is the best move for our family.
Our heart for this lengthy post is to express our love for
those at NCC, and our convictions about why we have decided to leave. We know
this specific doctrinal issue is a divisive one, and can be deeply personal.
Our heart is not to divide, but to pursue peace and unity with you until the very
end. We believe that can happen, even in our disagreement.
We are grateful for the pastors at NCC, who have done the
best they can in an extremely difficult situation, to communicate our reason
for leaving with the congregation. However, we do believe it is important for
you to hear from us personally. We would LOVE to sit down with all 600 of you
face to face, but we know that is impossible with the short time we have left
here. We aren’t naïve to the fact that even with the clearest of communication,
some will still probably misunderstand us. We’re ok with that. Our highest aim
is to please God, not man, but we will do our absolute best to make sure we are
at peace with everyone before we depart. That is our heart, and we give you
full permission to seek us out if you would like to engage about this issue.
If you remember one
thing from this post, let it be that our reason for leaving has never been
anything personal. Although our reason for leaving is a very personal issue, we
don’t leave here with enmity in our hearts toward anyone at NCC. We deeply love
NCC, and every person there. Period.
Below is just a brief explanation of the stance we have
taken, and what our convictions are. Keep in mind that this is not an
exhaustive exegesis of what the Bible teaches about complementarianism, but the
basics of why Adam and I have chosen to part ways with NCC.
As you have already heard, we are leaving NCC because we are
convicted about how the church should be run, and who should be running it. We
have taken a complementarian stance, as opposed to NCC’s egalitarian stance. As
complementarians, we believe that women are equal to men in dignity, value, and
worth and can serve in MANY leadership roles in the church. There are numerous
positions and opportunities for women to serve in, especially at NCC. Some of
the best church programs, and ministries, in this area are happening at NCC,
and very gifted and capable women are running them. Adam and I think that is
amazing, and we have loved supporting these women, and being a part of that! We
affirm these women, and their call to serve the church with their unique gifts.
We wish more godly, strong, and capable women would step up to serve and lead
at NCC! There are many of them and we don’t want to see them go to waste!
As complementarians,
we celebrate women and the unique gifts that God has given them. The fact that
we believe that women are equal to men in dignity, value, and worth, but with
distinct and complementary roles, cannot be stated enough.
For me personally, Adam has been the biggest support of my
unique God given gifts from the very start of our relationship. His affirmation
of the way God has made me, and the unique gifts I bring to our marriage, and
the local church, speak louder than the most sincere compliment from any other
person on this planet. My husband loves me and affirms me often! His sincere
encouragement in regard to my role as a wife, and a woman, pushes me forward to
experience the abundant freedom God’s design for women brings.
I think this is worth repeating…there is incredible freedom
in fulfilling the calling God has for men and women, in regard to their unique
roles as presented in scripture. We firmly believe this, and experience it in
our own marriage on a day-to-day basis.
Complementarianism does NOT condone subordination and/or patriarchal,
societal oppression of women. That is NOT what the Bible teaches. That is NOT
what Adam and I support. We affirm that Scripture intends for women to
flourish! We believe this happens when we live according to God’s Word, and His
design. Complementarianism is a beautiful thing for us, and we firmly believe
that our marriage wouldn’t be as strong as it is today if we chose to operate
in a manner not supported by scripture.
So, where is the
disagreement?
The issue for us comes in our conviction of who should be in
authority over the church. As complementarians, we believe that the office of
elder/overseer is reserved for men (specifically stated in 1 Timothy and Titus).
We believe the Bible is very clear on this, and that God has ordained specific
roles for men and women in the home, and (just as importantly!) the local church.
NCC has chosen to place women in the role of elder, and we cannot in good
conscience support that.
We see the theme of complementarianism modeled all throughout
Scripture starting with creation, and the created order. We also see it modeled
in the functional hierarchy of the Trinity, as the Son submits to the Father,
and the Spirit submits to the Father and the Son. We don’t believe the
qualifications for elders, in 1 Timothy and Titus, are based on the culture of
that time, which egalitarians would affirm. We believe the parameters for how
the local church should be governed, as stated in Scripture, is rooted in the
created order, and not something to be made more culturally acceptable for
today. The complementarian stance is definitely not culturally acceptable, or popular, but to be quite honest, we’re more concerned with obedience to the Word of God,
and pleasing Him.
So, why do we believe
this is a good reason to leave the church?
This is a very important question to ask in our culture of
consumerism. Hearts, and motivations, need to be seriously examined before
anyone decides to withdraw from their local church.
For us, we see this as an issue of Biblical authority. This
is not a gospel issue (aka a “matter of salvation”), but it deals with how
Scripture is dealt with and applies to our lives. We believe the complementarian standpoint is clearly stated in Scripture, and we are not willing to compromise our convictions as we seek to submit to Biblical authority. We believe
that submission to Biblical authority is of utmost importance, and a very good reason to
leave a church.
In this situation, someone must compromise. For
complementarians at NCC (Adam and myself) our conscience is violated as we sit
under a church government we don't see supported by scripture. At the same time, we
would never expect an egalitarian to feel completely comfortable serving, and
learning submissively, under a complementarian church government. Their
conscience would be violated as well!
Does this mean we have nothing to learn from each other? Of
course not! Adam and myself have learned a tremendous amount under NCC’s
leadership. We value, respect, and deeply love, each person (man and woman), who serves as a pastor or
elder at this church. Our prayer has always been that, despite our
disagreement, we would submit to our church leadership, and learn from them as
much as we can. We know we have not done that perfectly, but we hope we have
done it well.
With all that being
said, we firmly believe it will be better for the long-term peace of the
organization for us to leave.
We have been earnestly praying that NCC would choose to move
in a different direction, for a number of years now. God has not chosen to
answer our prayers in the way we desired, and that’s okay. Instead, He has
clearly shown us that since we are not in a position, nor do we have the
influence, to change the direction of NCC, it makes more sense for us to leave.
To protect unity, and to serve unhindered, we need to be in a place where our
convictions are in line with the church leadership we serve under.
I also think it’s worth mentioning that when Adam accepted
the worship leader position at NCC in 2009, he did not have these convictions,
and had no issue with the way NCC operates. This is something that God has
grown in him over the past four years, and opened his eyes to.
I’ll close by saying that during our time at NCC, we have
seen beautiful evidences of God’s grace at work in the leadership, and
congregation. We have seen individuals come to know Jesus, be baptized, and
grow in discipleship. We have participated in multiple small groups where the
fellowship was sweet, and life-long friendships were built. We were showered
with love, support, prayers, and extremely generous financial gifts, when we
jumped head first into a domestic adoption process.
We will never forget
these things.
We will always remember how God used the people at NCC to
grow us, refine us, and push us closer to Jesus.
It has truly been a privilege to serve here.
With deep love,
Adam and April Swiger